by Have you ever wondered why there are so few left-handed shortstops in Major League Baseball (MLB)? The question “Who are the left-handed shortstops in MLB history?” might have crossed your mind.
Read also How Many Players Are on a High School Baseball Team?
Introduction to Left-Handed Shortstops in MLB
Left-handed shortstops are a rarity in MLB, and this uniqueness adds to their fascination. Baseball fans are accustomed to seeing right-handed shortstops who excel in double plays and acrobatic fielding. Yet, with their unconventional approach, left-handed shortstops intrigue fans and scholars.
Historical Context: The Scarcity of Left-Handed Shortstops
Historically, MLB has seen very few left-handed shortstops. This scarcity is due to traditional beliefs about defensive positioning and player-handedness. Left-handed players are often steered towards outfield positions or pitching roles rather than infield duties.
Notable Left-Handed Throwing Shortstops
- Lou Gehrig: Known as “Iron Man” for his record of 2,130 consecutive games played, which was broken by Cal Ripken Jr. in 1995, Gehrig made a surprising appearance as a left-handed shortstop for the Yankees, debuting with a hit.
- Tom Chism: Primarily a first baseman for the Baltimore Orioles, Chism played shortstop in a 1979 game against the Toronto Blue Jays.
- Mark Ryal: In 1987, Ryal made history by playing shortstop as a left-handed thrower for the California Angels against the New York Yankees.
- Nino Escalera: Escalera played shortstop with a left-handed throw for the Cincinnati Reds in 1954, though he only spent one season in the MLB.
- Royce Stillman: Stillman holds the record for most games played by a left-handed thrower at shortstop, with six games during the 1975 season for the Baltimore Orioles.
Prominent Left-Handed Hitting Shortstops
While left-handed throwing shortstops are rare, several left-handed hitting shortstops have made their mark in MLB:
- Ozzie Guillen
- Johnny Pesky
- Joe Sewell
- Arky Vaughan
Keep reading to delve deeper into the history of left-handed shortstops in MLB!
The Legacy of Left-Handed Throwing Shortstops
Lou Gehrig, a name that surprises many baseball fans on this list, is remembered not only as one of the greatest first basemen but also for his brief stint as a left-handed shortstop. His debut at shortstop included a hit, adding to his legendary status.
Tom Chism and Mark Ryal also made brief appearances as left-handed shortstops, defying the norms of their time. Meanwhile, Nino Escalera and Royce Stillman had short but notable careers as left-handed throwers in the shortstop position.
Enjoy exploring the unique history of left-handed shortstops in Major League Baseball!
For more interesting reads, check out “How Long is a Little League Baseball Game?”
The Best Left-Handed Hitting Shortstops of All Time
Iconic Left-Handed Hitting Shortstops in MLB History
Johnny Pesky
Fenway Park’s “Pesky’s Pole” is a familiar landmark for Boston Red Sox fans, named after Johnny Pesky. Though not known for his power-hitting, Pesky hit only 17 home runs. The pole is named in his honor after he hit a crucial home run that barely stayed fair. The right field pole, often called a “short porch,” is just 302 feet from home plate. Despite his lack of power, Pesky was an excellent hitter, boasting a career batting average of .307. He served in the U.S. military for three years and amassed impressive hit totals in his first three MLB seasons with 205, 208, and 207 hits. From 1946 to 1951, he also led the league in runs scored. Pesky’s legacy is not just a foul pole but his remarkable consistency and skill at the plate.
Joe Sewell
Joe Sewell might not be a household name for younger baseball fans, but he was a formidable player in the 1920s and 1930s. Playing primarily for the Cleveland Indians and later the New York Yankees, Sewell’s career was marked by a .312 batting average and 1,054 runs batted in. Sewell is particularly noted for his incredible ability to avoid strikeouts, making him a formidable pitcher opponent. Despite his stature at 5’6″ and 155 pounds, Sewell’s skill with the bat earned him a place in the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1977.
Ozzie Guillen
Ozzie Guillen was known for his fiery personality and impressive skills as a left-handed hitting shortstop over a 16-year MLB career. Most of his playing years were spent with the Chicago White Sox, although he also played for the Baltimore Orioles, Atlanta Braves, and Tampa Bay Devil Rays. In 1985, Guillen won the American League Rookie of the Year Award with a .273 batting average and nine triples. Over his career, he maintained a .264 batting average and stole 169 bases. Guillen also had a successful stint as a manager, leading the White Sox to a World Series title in 2005 and later managing the Miami Marlins.
Arky Vaughan
Arky Vaughan, another left-handed shortstop, earned his place in the Baseball Hall of Fame with a career average of .318 and an on-base percentage of .406. Vaughan scored 1,173 runs, playing for the Pittsburgh Pirates and the Brooklyn Dodgers. Despite his impressive stats, Vaughan’s quiet demeanor may have kept him from becoming a household name. In 1945, Vaughan won the batting title with a .385 average and led the league in triples three times. He also led the league in stolen bases in 1943 at 31. Tragically, Vaughan’s life was cut short when he drowned in a fishing accident at age 40 in 1952.
The Absence of Left-Handed Throwers at Certain Positions
Left-handed throwers are rarely seen playing catcher, second base, third base, or shortstop due to several key factors:
Making Tags Easier
Infielders must make quick “swipe tags” when an opponent attempts to steal a base. With the glove on their left hand, right-handed players can perform this motion more efficiently. A left-handed fielder would need to catch the ball and then pivot to make the tag, slowing the process.
Momentum
Right-handed fielders naturally move towards first base on ground balls, making for a quicker throw. Left-handed fielders would have to stop, pivot completely, and then throw, which takes more time and disrupts the play’s momentum.
Timing
Speed is crucial in getting a fast runner out at first base. Left-handed throwers must pivot their bodies 180 degrees to make an accurate throw to first base, taking valuable milliseconds longer. In baseball, every inch and millisecond counts, and right-handed throwers can make these plays faster and with less strain on their arms.
Modern Left-Handed Shortstops
For insights into left-handed shortstops, explore the latest developments in MLB and see how today’s players continue to shape the game.
For more interesting reads, check out “How Long Are Kids Baseball Games?” and “How Much Does A Baseball Cap Weigh?”
Prominent Left-Handed Hitting Shortstops in MLB Today
Corey Seager
During the pandemic-shortened season, Corey Seager led the Los Angeles Dodgers to a World Series victory. He finished the season with a .307 batting average and 15 home runs. Seager also led the National League in doubles in 2019 with 44 extra-base hits. His consistent performance solidifies his place as one of the top significant shortstops for years to come.
Didi Gregorius
Standing 6’3″, Didi Gregorius is a potent left-handed hitter for the Philadelphia Phillies. Over his nine-year MLB career, Gregorius has scored 451 runs and hit 120 home runs. Besides the Phillies, he has also played for the Cincinnati Reds, Arizona Diamondbacks, and New York Yankees, showcasing his talent across multiple teams.
J.P. Crawford
Currently, with the Seattle Mariners, J.P. Crawford was drafted by the Philadelphia Phillies in the first round of the 2013 draft. Despite his defensive prowess, Crawford has faced challenges at the plate, often struggling to maintain a high batting average. Nonetheless, his defensive skills make him a valuable player.
Brandon Crawford
Brandon Crawford has been a reliable shortstop for the San Francisco Giants, entering his 11th season in 2021. Crawford has had a commendable career with 106 home runs and 564 batted in. His standout year was 2016, when he led the National League in triples.
JT Riddle
In 2020, JT Riddle joined the Pittsburgh Pirates after three seasons with the Miami Marlins. Although he has above-average power, Riddle has struggled with his batting average, impacting his daily ability to play. Despite these challenges, his size and skill suggest he will continue to play professionally for years to come.
For further reading, check out “The Difference Between Baseball Cleats and Football Cleats.”
Challenges Faced by Left-Handed Shortstops
Left-handed shortstops face unique challenges, such as adapting to unconventional fielding angles and navigating defensive positioning. Overcoming traditionalist skepticism requires determination and a commitment to mastering these hurdles.
Impact on the Game and Team Dynamics
The presence of left-handed shortstops adds an element of unpredictability and nuance to the game. Their unconventional approach contributes to a diversified team dynamic and challenges opponents’ expectations.
FAQs
What factors contribute to the scarcity of left-handed shortstops in professional baseball?
Historical norms and entrenched beliefs regarding player-handedness and defensive positioning limit the prevalence of left-handed shortstops in professional baseball.
How do left-handed shortstops influence team dynamics and strategy?
Left-handed shortstops add unpredictability and strategic complexity to team dynamics, challenging opponents and necessitating innovative defensive strategies.
Are left-handed shortstops as effective defensively as their right-handed counterparts?
While left-handed shortstops face unique challenges due to their defensive positioning, their effectiveness depends on their ability to adapt and acquire new skills.
How do managers strategize around the presence of a left-handed shortstop in the lineup?
Managers often configure defensive strategies to maximize the strengths of left-handed shortstops, enhancing their performance.
Are there any current left-handed shortstops in Major League Baseball?
Recent records indicate that there have been no prominent left-handed shortstops in Major League Baseball in recent years.
Conclusion
Left-handed shortstops are a testament to Major League Baseball’s capacity for evolution and innovation. From trailblazers like Larry Doyle and Bert Shepard to modern anomalies like Greg Harris and Glen Gorbous, their stories reflect the spirit of defiance and determination that shapes professional baseball.
